Minecraft Realms compared with running your own Minecraft server
Comparisons

Minecraft Realms vs Your Own Server: Which Does Your Group Need?

Realms is great for a small vanilla group. Here is exactly where it stops: mods, player count, crossplay and control, and how to move your world when you outgrow it.

Want your own server? Minecraft server hosting — plans, specs and regions.

November 16, 20266 min read
Share

On This Page

Minecraft Realms is Mojang's own server subscription, and for a lot of groups it's the first server they ever pay for. It's simple, it's official, and it works. It also has hard limits that you usually only find when your group outgrows them: wanting to play a modpack, adding an eleventh friend, or having a cousin on Xbox join a Java world.

Here's an honest comparison of Realms and running your own server, so you can tell which one your group needs.

What Realms gives you

Straight from Mojang's own Realms page, Realms for Java includes:

  • You + 10 players online at the same time. You can invite far more people (up to 10,000), but only 11 can play at once.
  • A personal server that's online 24/7, and friends play free.
  • Free backups and three world slots to switch between.
  • Cross-play on Windows, Mac and Linux. Java Realms do not cross-play with Bedrock devices or consoles.

Bedrock Realms are a separate subscription for consoles, phones and Windows Bedrock. Realms Plus includes Marketplace Pass content, and a Realms Pro tier exists for larger groups. Java and Bedrock Realms can't be mixed.

What Realms doesn't give you matters more. A Java Realm runs vanilla Minecraft. You can't install Forge, NeoForge or Fabric, so no mods, no modpacks and no server plugins. You don't choose the server's location or how much memory it has, and you can't see or edit its files.

Skip the setup headache

Get a server running in under 60 seconds.

Configure Server

Not ready to pay? Free 3-day trial, no card →

When Realms is the right choice

Be honest about this one: if your group is ten or fewer people playing vanilla Java Minecraft, Realms is a good product. Setup takes minutes, Mojang runs it, and there's nothing to configure. You don't need anything more.

When your own server is the right choice

Your own server (one you rent from a host, or run yourself) makes sense as soon as any of these are true:

You want to play a modpack. This is the most common reason groups move off Realms. ATM10, Cobbleverse, Better MC, Prominence II and the rest need a modded server, which Realms can't run. On a hosted server you pick the pack and it's installed for you. See our modpack server hosting for the full catalogue.

You want plugins. Land claims, economies, minigames, Discord chat bridges, anti-grief tools: all of these run on Paper and similar servers, not on Realms.

More than 11 people play at once. A Realm caps at you + 10 online. A server has no seat cap. You pay for memory and CPU, and the player count is up to you.

Your group is split between Java and Bedrock. Java Realms and Bedrock Realms can't talk to each other. A Java server running Geyser lets Bedrock players on consoles, phones and Windows join the same world. Our crossplay Minecraft servers come with that set up.

You care where the server is. Ping depends on distance. With your own server you choose a region close to your group.

You want control. Server properties, game rules, whitelists, scheduled restarts, world uploads and downloads, version choice: a server's files and settings are yours.

Side-by-side comparison

Realms (Java)Your own server
Players online at onceYou + 10No fixed cap, limited by RAM/CPU
Mods and modpacksNoYes
Plugins (Paper etc.)NoYes
Java + Bedrock togetherNoYes, with Geyser
Choose server regionNoYes
Choose RAMNoYes
Access to server filesNoYes
BackupsYesYes (automatic on most hosts)
Setup effortMinimalMinimal on a host, more if self-hosted

Moving your Realm world to your own server

You don't have to start over. Realms lets you download your world:

  1. In Minecraft, open Realms, select your Realm and choose Configure → World backups.
  2. Choose Download latest and the world is saved into your single-player worlds.
  3. Find that world folder in your Minecraft saves directory.
  4. Upload the folder to your server with the file manager in the server dashboard, and point the server at it (the level-name setting).

If you then add mods to that world, take a backup first. A vanilla world opens fine in most modded setups, but you can't remove mods from a modded world without losing their blocks.

The short version

Realms is the easiest way to run a small vanilla Java world, and if that's all you want, keep it. Once your group wants modpacks, plugins, more than eleven people online, or Java and Bedrock together, a Realm can't do it and your own server can. If you want to test that before paying, our free Minecraft server trial runs for 72 hours with modpacks included and no card. When you're ready, set up a Minecraft server in a few minutes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you put mods on Minecraft Realms?

Not on Java Realms. They run vanilla Minecraft only, so Forge, NeoForge and Fabric mods, modpacks and server plugins aren't supported. Bedrock Realms can use Marketplace content, which isn't the same as Java mods. To play a modpack with friends you need your own server.

How many players can join a Minecraft Realm?

For Java Realms, Mojang lists "You + 10 players" online at the same time. You can invite many more, but only 11 can play at once.

Can Bedrock players join a Java Realm?

No. Java Realms only cross-play across Windows, Mac and Linux Java. A Java server running Geyser is the usual way to put Java and Bedrock players in one world.

Is a Minecraft server better than Realms?

It depends on what you need. For a small vanilla group, Realms is simpler. For modpacks, plugins, more players, a chosen region or Java/Bedrock crossplay, a server is the only option.

Can I move my Realm world to a server?

Yes. Download the world from Realms (Configure → World backups → Download latest), then upload the world folder to your server and set it as the active world.

Skip the setup headache

Get a server running in under 60 seconds.

Configure Server

Not ready to pay? Free 3-day trial, no card →

Or see plans, specs and regions on Minecraft server hosting.